Synopsis
"The Battle of Russia," Chapter V of Frank Capra's "Why We Fight" series, follows the beginning of the end for Adolph Hitler.
1943 Directed by Frank Capra, Anatole Litvak
"The Battle of Russia," Chapter V of Frank Capra's "Why We Fight" series, follows the beginning of the end for Adolph Hitler.
Why We Fight: La battaglia di Russia
I really need to watch more Russian(USSR) films. I know NOTHING from there and this documentary instigates my quest for more knowledge.
Andrei Tarkovsky's masterpiece Solaris fuels my eagerness to maximum.
Side note: Where's the Mongolian cinema at?
Ano de Centenário de André Bazin: Repassando os filmes citados em Qu'est-ce que le cinéma? Filme #6
Esse é o meu favorito da série Why We Fight, não só por focar nos cercos de Leningrado e Stalingrado com os russos badasses motherfuckers, mas porque há a deliciosa ironia histórica em ver um filme do governo americano exaltando tanto a União Soviética stalinista.
WEBRip no MakingOff.
Perhaps the peak of Capra's World War II documentary exploits, THE BATTLE OF RUSSIA is an hour and a half deconstruction of the decisive war effort of the Eastern front. The information is so neatly packed in with the editing, the film almost feels alive with crackling energy. A triumphant look at the catastrophic failures of Germany's advances onto Moscow.
If the previous films were meant to demonstrate the dissolution of the Nazi invincibility myth, then this one utterly shatters it.
Mais um filme-propaganda produzido por Frank Capra como esforço de guerra pró-americanos. Dessa vez, deixando a Russia bem na fita ao mostrar a inacreditável resistência militar e civil soviética frente à invasão alemã, pouco tempo antes de virar a própria inimiga mortal durante a guerra fria. A montagem da sequência dos bombardeios nazistas em Leningrado, intercalados com a produção bélica em série russa, é um pequeno desbunde.
Oh how quickly the yankees turned their narratives
It still backs on the pre-clash of civilisation tones that made Capra's work on Japan so badly racist, but here are some gold pieces of history, specially military history, as well. Watch this movie if you still don't understand why the USSR invaded Finland or Poland, or if you think the Russian winter alone stopped Hitler. This explains strategy, ideological background, last-minute technological developments and so on.
I've seen professional historians of the USSR or of the World War II who aren't able to or simply don't understand how the Soviet people broke the Blitzkrieg like this movie does.
Of course it's propaganda (the film doesn't even mention the invasion of Finland…
#TheBattleofRussia
وثائقي عن الطمع في روسيا و دخولها في الحرب العالمية الثانية
حروب امتدت الى 800 عام ، هدوئها يعني بأنها تطبخ على نار هادئه بين روسيا و المانيا
مساحة روسيا جعلت من القوى العظمى على مر العصور بأنه يطمع فيها الى حد الجنون و الانتحار و ابتدئت العرب العالمية الثانية و هيتلر ضرب اول مسمار في نعشة عندما قرر بأن يدخل روسيا
اعظم تضحية فعلها الروس هي عندما حرقو مزارعهم بأنفسها لأجل ان يواجهو الالمان ، الحكومة الروسية رزقها الله بشعب يقدس ارضه فأنتصرت
فيلم بروباغندا روسية بها جوانب لهم الحق في ان يتفاخرو بها و به بعض الجوانب الجيدة ايضا
للتنوية : هذا فيلم صنع قبل نهاية الحرب العلمية2 بسنتين
ملاحظة : الفيلم يحتوي على مشاهد بشعة جدا
8/10
As history it is probably the worst of the series. The sanitizing of Russia's past and even present (1943) was disgusting though understandable. But this is not a work of history, but of propaganda; and as propaganda it may be the best. Not only does it depict the Germans as a scourge that needs to be crushed, but one that can be crushed and indeed was already in decline. It would have cheered me up at the time, though Poles, Ukrainians, Lithuanians, Finns, and many others would probably have thrown things at the screen.
"The citizens of Leningrad have proved, that generals may win campaigns, but people win wars".
The final one(s) I watched tonight - man, I'm probably the only person to have ever binged propaganda films. So this one is about double the length of an average one in this series, but it's also split into two parts. However, I just watched it as one whole part after just getting through two others. So for me to say that it felt a bit long near the end MIGHT be an unfair criticism. With that said, it didn't FEEL dreadful in length. If anything, it's still not as much of a slog as the first two in this series were, and those were half the length!
This one opens with text on screen explaining why they are making…
Frank Capra & Anatole Litvak used more time for detail explaining the Russian side of the war than any of the other entries of the Why We Fight war documentary series. You certainly get schooled. Not always as interesting, but it helps you understand the how large and different the battles where in the Soviet regions, than the ones going on in mainland Europe.
A weird document. It celebrates people's resilience fighting against Hitler's brand of fascism, but apologizes for Stalin's brand. Acts as a celebration of the Russian people and as an erasure of the genocides and slave labor perpetrated by Soviet leadership.
A grandiosa defesa russa aos cercos de Moscou, Leningrado e Stalingrado. Ao Frank Capra resta editar um vasto material de maneira didática e enfiar uma bandeira dos EUA aqui e outra ali pra parecer que eles foram importantes nessa história.
Mixing footage from classic movies like "Alexander Nevsky" with documentation of actual fighting, this movie tells the story of Russia's long-running defense against invaders, focusing largely on the then-current war Nazis. The story includes the ups and downs of the Nazi invasion, glorifying their scorched earth defense and ending triumphantly for the Russians. Considering the turnabout in American attitudes for Russian not long thereafter, the propagandistic sympathy engendered here is nothing short of remarkable.
*DISCLAIMER THIS REVIEW IS JUST FOR PART I*
The difference a few years can make… In this film there is unyielding praise for Russia. From its history, to leaders, culture, people, down to the very land itself this American documentary projects Russia in the most angelic light. In hindsight knowing the United States’ relationship with the USSR post-World War II, this is almost humorous to me. America has had a disdain for Russia which would reach its height just nineteen years after this documentary. In terms of the actual imagery, I thought it was beautiful. This may just be a compilation of old film footage, however what they use is some astounding reels, particularly that of the footage from Alexander…
Why we fight can usually be described using tired propaganda, but how we fight can be much more interesting—“The Battle of Russia” is the first film in the “Why We Fight” series to tell a really compelling story about one of the WWII campaigns (and it even got me to root for Russia)
Serinin önceki filmleri için aynı şeyi söyleyemeyeceğim fakat Capra burada hedefi on ikiden vuruyor. Ayrıca US Department of War elinden bu kadar iyi bir agitprop işi çıkması baya komik.
Oh how quickly the yankees turned their narratives
It still backs on the pre-clash of civilisation tones that made Capra's work on Japan so badly racist, but here are some gold pieces of history, specially military history, as well. Watch this movie if you still don't understand why the USSR invaded Finland or Poland, or if you think the Russian winter alone stopped Hitler. This explains strategy, ideological background, last-minute technological developments and so on.
I've seen professional historians of the USSR or of the World War II who aren't able to or simply don't understand how the Soviet people broke the Blitzkrieg like this movie does.
Of course it's propaganda (the film doesn't even mention the invasion of Finland…
Hollywood'dan sanırım bir daha benzeri görülemeyecek şekilde Rus halkına ve mücadelesine adanmış bir destan.
Film Stalingrad savunması ile Nazi Almanya'sının geri püskürtülmeye başlandığı günlerde propoganda için hazırlanmış.
Barbarossa Harekatı ile başlayan Nazilerin Rusya savaşı ve Rus halkının savunması üzerine savaşın sıcak günlerinde dönemin kaydını tutacak iyi bir belge film olmuş.
Why We Fight, Information Film 5...
operacja Barbarossa, amerykańska propaganda prosowiecka, NFR...
the fifth film of Frank Capra's Why We Fight documentary series, and the --top-- longest film of the series, consisting of two parts;
The film was made in collaboration with Lithuanian-born Anatole Litvak as primary director under Capra's supervision.
Litvak gave the film its "shape and orientation," and the film had seven writers with voice narration by Walter Huston.
The score was done by Russian-born Hollywood composer, Dimitri Tiomkin, and drew heavily on Tchaikovsky along with traditional Russian folk songs and ballads.
Film historian Christopher Meir notes that the film's popularity "extended beyond the military audience for it was initially intended, and was the second in the series…
Interesting that Russia got a free pass, temporarily, from capitalist USA because of Nazi Germany. That's simplifying history a lot, I know, but simple history is Why We Fight's specialty and I don't know very much of anything let alone European history. Why watch a documentary like this, a flimsy WWII propaganda, almost 80 years old? or, I don't know, something very current and close-to-home? I don't know. Just in terms of visual style, I think this picture is ok. Early historical catch-ups are a bit better than broader military slights and stuff, but I appreciate the editing. BATTLE OF RUSSIA was Chapter V of Capra’s “Why We Fight” series; so as just a Capra artifact I guess it's interesting…
-EUA em 1943 : A URSS tem um governo digno com seus cidadãos,e que vai ajudar o mundo a derrotar o fascismo. Viva o povo russo,viva a URSS.
-EUA após 1945 : A URSS come crianças no café da manhã. A CIA confirmou.
This movie is just so interesting. It's blatant USSR propaganda made by the US government, does not mention communism once I think and some of the things mentioned are quite interesting, knowing what we now know about the Soviet Union. But it's quite well made since it's Capra.
A very well made and pretty comprehensive wartime documentary. It is however propaganda and whilst it covers a large part of Russian culture and politics, communism is glaringly ommited. But as far as a one sided approach is taken it does seem to be very fair. Actually seems to odd to see such a positive American perspective on Russia which in a decade would be dominated by the Red Scare. Definitely worth a watch.
NeverTooEarlyMP 4,925 films
Every film that has ever been nominated for an Academy Award in any category. Enjoy!
Jayce Fryman 18,680 films
This list collects every film from the Starting List that became They Shoot Pictures Don't They's 1000 Greatest Films. This…
Artyficial 5,029 films
This list is the Letterboxd version of The Oxford History of World Cinema.
The book celebrates and chronicles over one…
Rose 5,488 films
Some are good, some are bad. some are respectful, others are NOT. From the deeply affecting Schindler's List to the…
Ryan 4,674 films
Movies that you may want to see and are available to stream for free on Amazon, if you have a…
Justin Wiemer 900 films
Compiled by Sam DiSalle at Mubi.com as of 1.19.19
all titles are gleaned from various sources, lists, interviews, etc. any…
emily 🖤 1,008 films
***This list only applies to what's listed on OpenCulture***
A massive list of free, legal films available online!
HUGE 2019…
khoss 1,488 films
2019 update: this list has not yet been updated with most of the 1923 films that just became public domain.…
Alan Silva 2,958 films
Lista de filmes, em ordem cronológica, sobre fatos da História Geral, da Pré-História aos dias de hoje. Para professores e…
Jayce Fryman 12,341 films
This will be the third time I am making this list. The first time, I saved poorly and lost it.…
Stephen Bush 814 films
The National Film Registry is a list of films deemed "culturally, historically or aesthetically significant" that are recommended for preservation…
buttguts 2,080 films
"just a big list of documentary/ish/informational video" migrating here from an old rym list ()
the idea is to not…