As a small-town Midwesterner, I too believe that one day I’ll run into my high school infatuation at the local grocery store. On impulse I’d probably walk quickly in the other direction, but it would be great to see our interaction unfold like this film: a little bit awkward, extremely nostalgic, and truly sentimental. 

I love watching people have conversations, and Sarah Paulson made this feel so real. The dialogue fit perfectly, and the expression of inside jokes and secondhand…