Like most horror anthologies it's a mixed bag. There's a couple great shorts, a couple decent ones and a couple poo ones. Not the best ratio, but the concept of covering one for each holiday is unique enough to give this bonus points.
Ya know, the more times I watch this, the more I come to really appreciate what it's got going for it. A couple of badasses posseing up and taking down THE vampire, across a dessert wasteland. Directed by Carpenter, with a score by him? It's the stuff of horror/western fans dreams. The claims of misogyny aren't completely baseless, but those offended need to actually sit back and look at the context from which it's coming, rather than just get butthurt at surface offences. I would've loved to see another movie or two with this crew.