Confusing’s review published on Letterboxd:
Classic Shyamalan, always there to disappoint. My main issue with Old is the plot, yes the story is interesting but the execution was bad. The whole movie was predictable and often lacks logic, it focuses more on the mystery and thriller aspects and negligees the characters, their development, and the deep aspect of it making it really lacking depth and there are also so many unimportant scenes that add absolutely nothing to the plot plus the very disappointing third act. To talk about the positive aspects I enjoyed the cinematography, every shot was beautiful and well filmed. Bottom line, it did not live up to my expectations at all.